Vote Qualified Judges
How we rate & source

Our method

We don't tell you how to vote. We gather what the bar associations and respected legal groups have already said about each judge, in their own words, and put it in one place — with a link to every original source.

Every rating, in the source's own words

Each association uses a different scale. Some say “Highly Qualified” and “Qualified.” Others say “Recommended” or report a percentage from an attorney poll. We never flatten those into one invented score. For every judge, we show each association's exact rating, the year it was issued, and a link to the source document.

A color tier — only to help you scan

Behind each rating we add one normalized tier, used solely for color-coding and at-a-glance scanning. The words you read are always the association's; the color is just ours.

Positive
Qualified, Highly Qualified, Recommended, and similar.
Mixed
Qualified with reservations, or split evaluations.
Not recommended
The association recommended against the judge.
Not yet rated
No 2026 evaluation has been published yet.

The summary badge

Each judge gets one plain-language badge — Highly Qualified, Broadly Qualified, Qualified, Mixed reviews, Not recommended, or Not yet rated — computed from the current-cycle ratings. The thresholds are intentionally forgiving of a single reservation: only a clear “not recommended,” or reservations that outnumber the positives, pulls a judge below qualified. The full scorecard is always shown so you can see exactly how the badge was reached.

Ratings arrive in the fall

Bar associations publish their evaluations close to the election — usually September and October. Until then, most judges will show “Not yet rated,” and a tracker on each profile counts how many associations have weighed in. Where an association rated a judge in a prior cycle but hasn't yet for 2026, we show the older rating clearly marked as a prior cycle — never as if it were current.

Where the names come from

The list of judges is drawn from the county election authorities (for retention) and the Illinois State Board of Elections (for contested seats), cross-checked against published guides. We update as official lists are certified.

Nonpartisan, by design

Vote Qualified Judges is a voter-education resource. We profile every judge on the ballot, surface independent evaluations, and link you to each judge's own pages and to nonpartisan guides — so the decision stays yours.

See the rating sources we draw from →

Make sure your voice counts